TL;DR
- The standard advice (pick a topic, search, join, introduce yourself, post daily) is the reason you feel stuck. It has almost nothing to do with how real online communities actually form.
- Most disappointing groups are not the wrong topic. They are the wrong verb. Same subject, completely different activity happening inside.
- You do not go find a community. You go find something you needed, and your people are standing right next to it. You find your people sideways.
- A community is not 11,000 members. It is three or four people whose brains you enjoy reading.
- Lurking counts. It is the first half of the job, done correctly.
- Run the 5 minute vibe check on any room before you decide it is a bust: read the comments, find a disagreement, look for a joke, look for repeat names, check for repeated questions.
- Not every room needs to be a living room. Some are pharmacies. Some are bulletin boards. All three are legitimate.
Podcast: Play in new window | Download
Subscribe: Spotify | Amazon Music | iHeartRadio | RSS | More
The advice everyone gives you, and why it is not working
Here is the play you have read a hundred times. Step one, decide what you are interested in. Step two, search for a group about it. Step three, join. Step four, introduce yourself. Step five, engage every day so people get to know you.
Every article. Every video. Same five steps.
I have found my people online more times than I can count. Thirty years of doing this, across bulletin board systems, forums, Facebook groups, Reddit, and Discord. While I was writing this episode I realized something that genuinely stopped me: I have never done a single step on that list. Not one. Not once.
So if you have tried the five steps and ended up in a group you never open, you did not fail at community. You followed directions that do not describe the thing they claim to describe.
Quick note on who this is for. If you are a parent trying to find other parents who actually get what you are dealing with, yes, this is for you. And if you do not have kids and you just want somewhere to talk about a court case or a video game or a water bottle because nobody in your house cares even a little bit, this is also for you.
Two Facebook groups. Same water bottle. Completely different rooms.
There are two large Facebook groups for fans of Owala water bottles. Same brand. Same product. And if you have watched me for longer than about five minutes, you know I am a little bit obsessed with these things.
I am in one of those groups constantly. The other one I joined and almost never open.
The difference is not the topic. The topic is identical. The difference is what people are actually doing in there.
In one group, people talk about their bottles. Customizations, new colors, what dropped this week. In the other group, people are basically just buying and selling them.
I do not want to buy one bottle from somebody. I want to talk about bottles.
Same topic. Different verb.
The verb test, defined
The verb of an online group is the activity actually happening inside it, as opposed to the subject it says it covers. Common verbs include talking, helping, asking, selling, teaching, sharing stories, and making fun of something. Two groups can share a topic and be completely different places to spend your time.
I would bet money that at least one of the groups you are disappointed in right now is not the wrong topic. You joined the wrong version of the right group. That is a fifteen second fix once you know to look for it.
You do not find a community. You find something you needed.
1995: I joined for a boy
Picture this. It is 1995. I am in high school and there is this boy. He is into computers. I am into him.
I find out he spends time on a BBS. For anybody under 40, a BBS is a bulletin board system, basically the very first version of an online forum. And it worked exactly like it sounds: you used your home phone line to dial directly into it. It tied up the entire house’s phone. My mother loved it. (She did not love it.)
I got on there entirely to talk to that boy more.
What I found instead was a room full of people who were like me. My geeky people. Genuinely the first time in my life I had been anywhere that being into computers was the normal thing to be into instead of the weird thing. This was the nineties, remember. Not everybody had a computer in the house, and the movie Hackers had weirdos like me yelling “hack the planet” at each other.
I never did get that boy to like me. I did get friends.
Early 2000s: I joined for Buffy backstory
Fast forward. I am watching Buffy the Vampire Slayer, but I came in around season two or three and had missed the entire beginning.
Younger readers, this was when Netflix mailed you physical DVDs. There was no binging. No streaming back to season one. No wiki. No 40-minute recap video waiting for you on YouTube. If you wanted to know who somebody was and why everyone was so upset about them, you needed other humans who had actually watched it.
So I went looking for Buffy backstory and landed on a forum called MightyBigTV, which later became Television Without Pity, and which does not exist at all anymore.
Those people dissected every episode line by line. They had inside jokes. There was a whole running bit about Spike calling everybody out for not remembering who Glory was, and once you were in on it, it stayed funny for years. I still laugh when I hear “is everybody here very stoned?”
Two stories, years apart. I went to one for a boy and one for a TV show. I left both of them with people.
Which is how I finally understood the thing nobody says out loud: you do not go find a community. You go find something you needed, and your people are standing right next to it. You find your people sideways.
Ask this question instead
Stop asking “what community should I join?” That question has no answer, and it is exactly why you are stuck.
Ask this instead:
Where do I already go looking for answers?
Your last ten searches are a map. Seriously, go look at them.
- The comment section on the recipe site you use every week
- The subreddit that fixed your printer at 11 o’clock at night
- The Discord you joined for one game and never opened again
- The Facebook group you joined to sell a stroller
You have already been standing in the room. You just walked in for a different reason and never looked up.
Which platform is best for finding an online community?
Here is the honest 90-second version, because the platform matters far less than the verb.
| Platform | Best for | The catch |
|---|---|---|
| Facebook groups | Easiest if you already live on Facebook. Unbeatable for anything local and for very specific hobbies. | The worst one for repetition. The same question every week, forever. |
| Finding a room about literally anything, no matter how strange. The single best place on earth to lurk. | Nobody will ever notice you are there. | |
| Discord | Real-time conversation. Fantastic once you are a regular. | Walking into an active one feels like showing up to a party an hour late where everybody already has an inside joke going. Hard if you are a skimmer. |
| Old school forums | Nearly extinct, and still honestly the best format anybody ever built for this. Reading and being read. | There are not many left. |
My actual answer: the best platform is not the optimal one. The best platform is the one you will actually open. The one already on your phone. And none of it matters at all until you have matched the verb.
A community is three or four people whose brain you enjoy
Back to that Buffy forum.
I would read something somebody posted and think, “yes, exactly, that is what I thought and could not say.” Then a week later I would read something else and go, “huh, that is the same person, and I still agree with them.” Then it happened again.
At some point I stopped reading the forum and started scanning it for about four usernames. I would open a thread and my eyes would go looking for them first.
I barely ever talked to any of them directly. Almost zero back and forth. What was happening was simply reading and being read.
So here is the rule.
A community is three or four people whose brain you enjoy.
If you are sitting there waiting to feel like you belong to a group of 11,000 people, you will wait forever, because nobody belongs to 11,000 people. That is not a thing that happens to anyone.
You know the whole Cheers idea, where everybody knows your name? Nobody actually needs the entire bar. You need the four people sitting at the end of it. You never see the stories of everybody else in that bar. You only see Norm and Cliff and Sam and Diane.
The two-week name exercise
This costs you nothing, and it works.
- For two weeks, read like you normally would. No pressure to post. No pressure to do anything.
- When somebody’s take makes you nod, or laugh, or think “huh, I had not considered that,” write that name down. An actual note in your phone.
- When a name shows up twice, you have found your person.
- At four names, you have a community. Even if you have never spoken to a single one of them.
The Ditto Rule: why lurking counts
I have a rule for myself that I had never said out loud until I sat down to write this.
I do not say “ditto.” If somebody has already said the thing, I am not going to add a “same” underneath it. I will like the comment and move on. That is not a contribution; that is noise. If I have something unique to say, something nobody in the thread has said yet, then I say it. If I do not, I do not.
Call it the Ditto Rule.
What the Ditto Rule means in practice is that I lurk. A lot. Decades of lurking. There are rooms I have been reading for years where I have maybe posted six times.
If you have been in a group for a year and never posted once, you are not a failure at community. You are doing the first half of it correctly.
Now let me be fair with you about the second half.
The reason those four people on that Buffy forum eventually knew who I was is that I did eventually post. Lurking gets you in the room. Posting is what makes you findable. You cannot be read if there is nothing to read.
Here is the good news: it is not a volume problem. One good post a month, on something where you genuinely had a different take, will do more for you than thirty “this!” replies ever will.
The Ditto Rule is not an excuse to never speak. It is permission to only speak when it is worth it.
The 5-minute vibe check: how to tell if a group is worth your time
When people ask me how I decide whether a group is for me, my honest answer has always been “vibes.” Which is a completely useless thing to say to another human being.
So I slowed it down and figured out what I am actually doing. It turns out to be five specific things, and it takes about five minutes.
1. Skip the posts. Read the comments.
You may need the post for context, so skim it. Then read the comments carefully.
The post tells you what a group says it is about. The comments tell you what it actually is. Posts are the advertising. Comments are what is happening in the room.
2. Scroll until you find a disagreement
There is always one, especially in bigger groups. And the question is not whether people disagreed. I like disagreement. I am not looking for a room where everybody nods at each other.
The question is: what happened to that person? Were they answered, or were they dealt with?
Here is how I learned that one. In a big group for my city, somebody posted a video saying drivers were blowing through her stop sign while she was working as a crossing guard at an elementary school. I watched the video and, whether it was the angle or something else, it did not show that. The cars in it were not even on the side of the road she would have been stopping traffic for.
So I said so, politely. Something like, hey, I would not roast these particular cars, it does not look like you were stopping those ones.
And I got piled on. Not for being wrong about the video. For apparently not caring about kids’ safety.
I was right about the video. But that is not the useful part. The useful part is that in about ten minutes, that room showed me exactly what it does with a differing opinion. That is data. And because I only speak up when I have a take nobody has said yet, I tend to find this out fast. I am the canary.
I am still in that group, by the way. It is one of the biggest ones for my city and I want to know when a road is closed. I just do not say things there anymore. More on that in a second.
3. Look for a joke. Any joke.
A room with no jokes in it is not a community. It is a service desk.
Which is fine. Sometimes you need a service desk. Just know which one you walked into so you are not sad about it later.
4. Look for repeat names
If the same handful of people turn up everywhere, there are regulars, and that means you can become one.
If it is all strangers passing through, there is no room to be in. There is just a lobby.
5. Check whether the same question is on the page twice
If it is, that is chronic repetition. And chronic repetition means nobody is staying. People show up, get their answer, and leave. Nothing accumulates.
Not every room needs to be a living room
There are at least three kinds of rooms, and all three are legitimate.
| Room type | Why you go | What it looks like when it is working |
|---|---|---|
| The living room | You go because you like being in there. No errand. | Ongoing conversation, regulars, inside jokes, tangents. |
| The pharmacy | You go when you need something specific. You get it and you leave. | Quiet for months, then exactly the right help on the day you need it. |
| The bulletin board | You read it for information and you do not participate. | You stay informed and you never post. |
My pharmacy
I am in a support group for ulcerative colitis. I have had it since I was about 12, so I know a lot about the disease. And I want to point out that I joined that one exactly the way the standard advice says. I searched for it, found it, joined on purpose.
And it works. It does its job perfectly.
But I only go when I am actively dealing with symptoms and I need to commiserate with people who genuinely get it. Then I do not go for months.
For a long time I felt like that meant I had failed at that group. Like I was doing community wrong.
I was not. That is a pharmacy. Going only when you need it is not a failure. It is what that room is for.
My bulletin board
Remember that city group? It used to be a living room for me. After the crossing guard thing, I demoted it to a bulletin board.
I did not leave. I still read it every week. I just stopped putting opinions into it.
You are allowed to stay in a room and stop talking in it. That is not defeat. That is correctly identifying what a room can hold.
The rule: decide what this room is for, then stop being disappointed that it is not something else.
Half the loneliness people feel about their groups is a group being perfectly good at being a pharmacy while they sit there waiting for it to become a living room.
How you know you found the real thing: it has its own language
Ben IS Glory?!?!
Twenty-some years ago on a Buffy forum, that meant everything. If you were there, you are smiling right now. If you were not, those three words mean absolutely nothing to you. That is exactly the point.
Here is a current one. I watch Emily D. Baker, who covers court cases, and I am obsessed. Her community is laced with pop culture and inside jokes. During the Kouri Richins trial, which was here in Utah, so I actually got to attend a day of it, an attorney said he would like to reference the case of Takesies v. Backsies, meaning he would like to take his position back, please.
That community adopted it instantly. They still say it constantly, about everything.
Two completely different topics, twenty years apart, identical phenomenon.
Inside jokes are not decoration. They are proof that people stayed in a room together long enough to build something. You cannot fake it and you cannot manufacture it. You just have to be there when it happens.
Which is the whole reason lurking counts.
Fine, run the test on me
I just spent this entire post handing you a checklist for auditioning a room. It is only fair that I hand you mine and let you run it.
The verb first.
There is a very large digital parenting group on Facebook, which I am not going to name, that is run by a kids tech brand. Every day the same six questions get asked, and a moderator points to the same canned answers, which, shockingly, point back to that brand’s website.
That is not a knock on the people in there. It is structural. A room whose only verb is Q&A will repeat forever, because there are only so many questions. Story rooms do not repeat, because nobody else has your stories.
So the verb in my rooms is not Q&A. Yes, we absolutely help each other. But the actual thing we do is talk about the technology in our houses like it is shared life experience. “I just found out you can do this with your lights.” “My kid did this, how do I fix it?”
And the ridiculous stuff, for example…
Last night my husband had people over for game night. Six adults sitting around my kitchen table, barely moving, because they were playing a board game. And every ten minutes, the lights went out.
Every ten minutes. Because I had set the kitchen lights to shut off after ten minutes of no motion at night, which is a fantastic setting right up until six people sit very still in a room for three hours. Somebody had to stand up and wave at the ceiling every ten minutes like they were flagging down a plane.
He was so annoyed with me.
That is not a question. It is not a tip. It is “you will not believe what my house did to my husband.”
That is the verb.
Three doors, three verbs
Run the test on all three of these and pick the one that matches what you actually want to do.
- The Digital Village (Facebook group). Easiest if you already live on Facebook. Most conversational. This is the one I am trying to build into a living room.
- r/familytech (Reddit). Best if you want to lurk indefinitely and never be perceived by anyone, which, again, is allowed. I would love more conversation there if Reddit is your comfortable place.
- My Discord server. The newest, fastest, most real time of the three. Link is in the podcast description, because nobody should have to write down a whole URL while they are listening.
I will be honest with you. I just told you that walking into a Discord feels like showing up to a party an hour late. I am also the person who just built one. So we are all figuring that room out at the same time, which is genuinely the best possible moment to walk into one. Nobody has any inside jokes yet. We get to make them together.
And here is my invitation, which is the exact opposite of “introduce yourself in the comments.” You are allowed to join and say nothing. Read for a month. Read for six months. And when your house does something ridiculous, or you are at your wit’s end trying to figure out how to make your lights turn off after ten minutes of inactivity, that is your first post.
Your challenge this week (15 minutes)
Pick one group, subreddit, forum, or server you are already in and have never really looked at. Spend 15 minutes reading comments, not posts. Then answer three questions.
- What is the verb in here? Are people talking, helping, selling, or making fun of something?
- What happened the last time somebody disagreed? Were they answered, or were they dealt with?
- Did any name come up more than once?
That is the whole assignment. You might find out you have been in the wrong version of the right group this entire time.
Bonus round, only if you feel like it. If while you are in there you find a take nobody has said yet, say it. One post. That is how the four names find you.
The specific kind of lonely nobody talks about
It is not being alone.
It is having a thing you love and nobody to say it to. It is caring a completely unreasonable amount about something and watching everybody at your own dinner table not care at all. Just let me say the name Karen Reed around my family and watch the eye rolls.
And somewhere out there is a room full of people who want to talk about that exact thing. Water bottles. A trial. Your smart lights. Season three of a show that went off the air in 2003.
It is not silly, and you are not too late.
You are just not in the room yet.
Go find your people.
Frequently asked questions
How do I find an online community that actually fits me?
Stop searching for a community and start noticing where you already go looking for answers. Your recent searches, the subreddit that solved a household problem, the group you joined for one transaction. Then check the verb in that room, meaning what people are actually doing there, not what the topic is. Most disappointing groups are the right topic and the wrong verb.
Why do I feel like I do not belong in my Facebook groups?
Usually one of two reasons. Either the verb does not match what you want (you want conversation, the room does selling or Q&A), or you are measuring belonging against the whole membership number. Nobody belongs to 11,000 people. Belonging is three or four people whose posts you look forward to reading.
Is it bad to lurk in an online group without posting?
No. Lurking is the first half of the job, done correctly. It is how you learn the room’s language, spot the regulars, and figure out whether it is worth your time. The second half is eventually posting once in a while, because you cannot be read if there is nothing to read. One good post a month beats thirty “same!” replies.
What is the best platform for finding an online community?
The one you will actually open. Facebook groups are strongest for local and hobby specific communities. Reddit is best for niche topics and for lurking. Discord is best for real time conversation once you are a regular. Traditional forums are nearly extinct but are still the best format ever built for reading and being read. The platform matters much less than the verb.
How can I tell if a Facebook group is toxic before I join?
Do the 5 minute vibe check. Read the comments instead of the posts, scroll until you find a disagreement and see whether that person was answered or dealt with, look for at least one joke, look for repeat names, and check whether the same question appears twice on the page. That last one signals nobody is staying long enough to build anything.
Do I have to post every day to be part of an online community?
No. Daily posting is advice built for growing an audience, not for finding people. Consistent reading plus occasional genuine contributions builds real connection more reliably than volume.
What if I only use a group when I need something?
That is a pharmacy, and it is a completely legitimate kind of room. Support groups and troubleshooting communities are often at their best exactly this way. The mistake is feeling like you failed because a pharmacy did not become a living room.
Join the Digital Village!
- The Digital Village on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/groups/thedigitalvillage
- r/familytech on Reddit: https://www.reddit.com/r/FamilyTech/
- Discord server: https://discord.gg/A2gNTEgsd3
This is Family Tech, powering down.
Keep Reading
- Tech Conversations to Have with Your Kids
- Technology Use Contract
- Asking Your Kids Before You Post: The Veto, The Undo, and The Handoff
This post may contain affiliate links, which means I receive compensation if you make a purchase using the links.
